Engineering Guide

Die Casting vs CNC Machining for Aluminum Parts

When aluminum parts should move from CNC machining to die casting: tooling and unit cost, design rules, porosity, tolerances, finishing limits and the volumes where each process makes sense.

Die Casting vs CNC Machining for Aluminum Parts

A machined aluminum housing is perfect for 50 units — and painful at 20,000, when every part still needs hours of machine time. Die casting can bring the unit cost down sharply, but it needs a die, a different design and different expectations about material and finish. The question is not which process is better, but at what volume and with which design changes the switch pays off.

Side by side

Aluminum part processes by volume from CNC machining to die casting.
The switch point depends on part size, complexity and lifetime volume.
FactorCNC machiningDie casting
ToolingNone (fixtures only)Steel die — significant one-time cost and weeks to make
Unit costDriven by machining time; stays relatively flat with volumeLow per part once the die exists
Typical alloys6061, 7075 and other wrought alloysCasting alloys such as A380 / ADC12
TolerancesTight, consistentLooser as-cast; critical features are machined afterwards
Internal qualitySolid wrought materialSome porosity is normal; matters for pressure-tight or highly stressed parts
FinishingAnodizes wellAnodizing is limited by silicon-rich alloys; powder coat or paint is common
Design changesEasy — change the programExpensive — modify the die

Designing for die casting

  • Uniform walls (thick sections cause porosity and shrinkage)
  • Draft on walls in the die opening direction
  • Generous radii and ribs instead of thick blocks
  • Bosses cored out and connected with ribs
  • Machining allowance only where precise features are needed
  • Gate and overflow locations away from cosmetic faces

Questions to ask before switching

A die-casting quote is only comparable to a machining quote when it covers the whole route. Ask each supplier to break the cast part down so you can see where the cost really sits:

  • Die cost, number of cavities and expected die life in shots
  • Trimming, deburring and secondary machining per part — and who does it
  • Which features are as-cast and which are machined, marked on the drawing
  • Porosity acceptance criteria and how they are checked (sectioning, X-ray, leak test)
  • Surface finish options for the chosen alloy and how cosmetic faces are protected
  • Lead time to first samples and how many sample rounds are included

A common mistake is sending the machined design unchanged to a die caster. Sharp internal corners, deep pockets without draft and uneven walls that were free in machining become porosity, sticking and long cycle times in casting. Expect a redesign round, and budget time for it before the volume ramp, not during it.

A practical middle path

Some projects use both processes at once: a near-net-shape casting for the bulk of the part, followed by CNC machining of mating faces, bores and threads. This keeps tight tolerances where they matter while removing most of the machining time.

How to decide

  1. Estimate lifetime volume, not just the first order.
  2. Get quotes for both: CNC unit price vs. die cost plus cast-and-machine unit price.
  3. Check whether the casting alloy and its finish meet your requirements (strength, corrosion, appearance).
  4. Plan a bridge: keep machining while the die is made and samples are approved.
  5. Re-qualify the part after the switch — castings behave differently from machined parts.

Machining cost drivers are explained in CNC machining cost; material choice in aluminum vs steel vs stainless. Send your part and volumes to compare both routes.

Related

Case studies

Detailed case studies are being prepared.

We only publish real projects, with our clients’ approval. If you would like to see examples relevant to your product, ask us in your request — we can share suitable references privately.

Ask about relevant projects

Insights

More guides

All insights

Have a product or part to manufacture?

Send us your drawings, CAD files or a short description. An engineer will review your request and reply with questions or a quotation.