Engineering Guide

What a DFM Review Should Cover (and What to Ask Your Supplier)

What a design-for-manufacturing (DFM) review should include for molded, machined, sheet metal and electronic parts, what a useful DFM report looks like, and the questions to ask before tooling.

What a DFM Review Should Cover (and What to Ask Your Supplier)

Many suppliers say “DFM done” after a quick look at your CAD. A real design-for-manufacturing review is different: it predicts the problems you would otherwise discover in T1 samples, failed assemblies or high unit costs — while changing the design still costs nothing but engineering time. Knowing what a thorough review contains lets you ask for one.

When to do it

DFM review between detailed CAD and release for tooling.
Review before release — changes after tooling cost far more.
  • Before final quotation — so the price reflects the design that will actually be made
  • Before cutting tooling — the last cheap moment to change molded or cast parts
  • Before PCB layout is frozen — DFM and DFT (design for test) for electronics
  • Again after any significant design change

What the review should check, by process

ProcessTypical DFM checks
Injection moldingWall thickness and transitions, draft, ribs and bosses, undercuts, gate location and weld lines, sink/warp risk, parting line, ejector marks on cosmetic faces
CNC machiningTool access, internal radii, deep pockets, thin walls, number of setups, tolerances that drive cost, thread specifications
Sheet metalBend radius and relief, flange length, hole-to-bend distance, hardware placement, weld distortion, flat-pattern feasibility
PCB assemblyComponent availability, footprints and spacing, polarity marks, thermal relief, test points, panelisation, programming access
AssemblyTolerance stack-ups, assembly sequence, fasteners count and type, fixtures, cable routing, serviceability

Process-specific rules are in our guides to injection molding design, CNC tolerances and sheet metal design.

What a useful DFM report looks like

  • An issue list, each item with a screenshot or marked-up drawing
  • Severity: must-fix (cannot be made / will fail), should-fix (yield, cost, cosmetics), optional (nice to have)
  • A proposed change for each issue, not only the problem
  • Cost or lead-time impact where relevant
  • For molded parts: gate location, parting line and ejector positions shown on the part; mold-flow results for critical parts
  • Open questions the supplier needs you to answer

Questions to ask your supplier

  1. Which features drive most of the cost — and what would change if we relaxed them?
  2. Where will gates, parting lines and ejector marks be, and are any on cosmetic surfaces?
  3. Which dimensions do you consider hard to hold, and how will you measure them?
  4. Which components or materials have long lead times or single sources?
  5. What would you change if this were your product?

Acting on the findings

Decide each item in writing, update the CAD and drawing revision, and ask the supplier to confirm that the next quote and tooling are based on the new revision. Track open items to closure before releasing tooling — a DFM report that nobody closes out is just a list of future problems.

DFM is part of our product development work. Send your CAD files for a review before you commit to tooling.

Related

Case studies

Detailed case studies are being prepared.

We only publish real projects, with our clients’ approval. If you would like to see examples relevant to your product, ask us in your request — we can share suitable references privately.

Ask about relevant projects

Insights

More guides

All insights

Have a product or part to manufacture?

Send us your drawings, CAD files or a short description. An engineer will review your request and reply with questions or a quotation.